1897 Island SG:IS38 Rare 3/5aur Large overprint Prir,is it?

Perhaps Robert WERT could do the magic with his software and show which is on top, the surcharge 3 , prir or the cancel?

I agree that would be the happiest result,…….. but black on top of black is always going to be tricky . Good luck with the result

Great details, pics, markings... Robert!

A couple of comments:

1. Two separate cancels means one will be over the other. Doesn't necessarily mean 2nd cancel is fake. Only that it was the 2nd cancel applied.
2. The extra part on the right side of the stem on the 2nd "r" seems to be normal one type of the genuine overprints. So in this case, I don't think it is a double overprint, but its normal state.

To me, the question is not the order of the surcharge/overprint/cancel, but whether all 3 are genuine. Morten has some examples of genuine surcharge/overprint types, along with a wide variety of forgeries, on his website. The prir overprint looks close to one of the genuine overprints (the one with a level base, not the one with the elevated "i"), but still looks a little different in other spots. But I don't know if those small differences are typical for genuine. Hopefully, classicalstamps can chime in.

A little late feedback, fixing the caravan too ..., thank you very much for good expert help.

The image is cut at the very edge of the piece of paper, but I cut the image so that I straightened it up a bit to get a "calmer" image. The piece itself is not larger, you can see some of the edges in the lower corners.
I could have taken a new picture but it has also been sent to Germany. Because Mr Møller asked me to take the stamp off the paper for a better assessment of the watermark. WM that I thought should NOT be on this brand?

At least what I found on stampworld, colnect etc. I do not have Icelandic Literature yet, books are shamefully expensive in Norway. I recently bought some manuals for Posthorn Norway. Hundreds of dollars just for that.
There's something I never want to understand, the prices of philately literature / catalogs .... but that's another topic

So I grew out of what Mr Møller said, something I otherwise would never have done in this case. I found standing King's Crown. Then he said I SHOULD send this for verification. He got many good scanners first and was positive.

I agree with what is found here, the truth can be brutal. But as the rest of you say, even though the order may seem whimsical on cancel etc, it MUST not be false for that reason.
When it comes to "prir"
I found a database of fake and original prints. When I via photoshop put the real over, fit perfectly.

So this is possibly an object that requires deep consideration..more assessments. I first sent it to one of the most renowned experts in Norway, they approved of the stamp itself and overprints, but would not conclude on the order. So therefore forwarded on the recommendation of the Norwegian expert.
I will find the picture watermark again

on this picture i see some red and black dots

wm, standing crown

Mr Møller said there is a one stamp with the same overprints and standing crown, so if mine is correct it will be the second one

if I understood this correctly 

NordicTraveler..You are welcome...A lot of people fly speck and some don't...Last opinion, just going back to collecting stamps.

Robert

Hi NordicTraveler
If you are serious about flyspecking, remember what i tell collectors at our stamp club...Just 2 sentences.

1 - See what is there that should not be there.
2 - See what is not there that should be.

Robert

Hello

then the answer has come from Germany and that was good news. The stamp is genuine, overprint 3 and Prir are genuine (large) and cancel is genuine.

Afa No. 18, Type BII
But no info on the rarity of BII, anyone know anything?

cancel the day after release

khjsorry, I should not have said it until I find the page again, it was not saved and it is a while ago, looking

No problem. I've got enough to work with as it is.

But if you ever find it, please post and tag me so that I will see it.

Thank you, and again, congratulations and well done!

stampforgeries.com/iceland/?fbclid=IwAR1KBHyCyFyJz6o6vjUJHhkeAbYXnwzN0e5psL33TBtf4AWsv4TFMJevd44

Try this link